Mary Wernke
F.C. Tucker Top 10 Realtor, 2018

Meet Mary: Focused & Driven

When you live and breathe real estate like I do, you deliver results. It’s that simple. With a laser-focused, committed attitude and a wealth of knowledge, I’ve been a top-performing Realtor here in Indianapolis (and previously Chicago) for over a decade. I pour myself into my work and provide clients like you unparalleled expertise and support. But that’s not all I bring to the table. I have an uncanny eye for aesthetics and the ability to project home values and staging needs on the spot. I can share expert design and remodel ideas and estimates, and help you envision what might be. I’m honored to have been recognized as one of F.C. Tucker’s Top 10 Realtors in 2018, 2019 & 2020, along with earning over $300 million in total real estate sales!

Meet Jenn Sutton

Meet Jenn Sutton

Jenn brings her love of helping and connecting with people, along with her expert knowledge of real estate investment and renovation to her real estate career. We are very excited to have her on the team!

Learn More
Meet Christian Payne

Meet Christian Payne

Christian knows what it takes to win. After a decade of leading championship teams as a collegiate athletic director and lacrosse athlete, Christian coaches his clients to achieve their victories. He will guide you to develop an effective home buying or selling game plan and deliver a competitive advantage. Christian’s relationship building and marketing strengths will position you to capitalize on your best opportunity.

Learn More

The real estate game never stays the same. You need a bold, nimble Realtor who stays on top of the market and your goals.


I’ve built vast personal and professional connections over the years. I can connect you with top-notch services, contractors, and any resources you might need.


Real estate is both an art and a science. From reimaging a space to home valuation, you’ll have access to my spot-on market intuition and vision.

relocation services

I recently purchased a house through Mary and she truly went above and beyond. She was extremely proactive, knowledgeable and understands the market. I always knew where things stood throughout the process and her attention to detail was unparalleled. Even after closing, she continues to check-in and it's evident that she sincerely makes her clients a top priority. I highly recommend Mary and would absolutely work with her again.

Sarah Gunn

Mary was everything you could possibly ask for in a Realtor and more. She was prompt, diligent and relentless when it came to helping us find a buyer for our house & closing the deal for our new home. Mary went above and beyond what we could have expected. We would not have closed on our transactions without her help and follow-through.

Becca & Jonathan Polak
Tech Executive & Attorney

As first time homebuyers, we had so many questions and concerns, and Mary was always very helpful in making us feel completely at ease. We valued her professional advice and her knowledge throughout the entire process. She was easy and quick to communicate with, and was very flexible with our busy schedules. Mary was able to find a home that was perfect for us in our very first week of working together. We could not have been more pleased with our home buying experience. She is truly one of the best.

Carly Dannenmueller & Leland Hollensbe
Butler University & IU Health

Throughout our home buying/selling process, Mary was a wonderful partner to us. Her genuine, friendly personality mixed with her knowledge of the Indy real estate market, awesome negotiation skills, and attention to detail made the process seamless. Thanks to Mary, we love our new home and neighborhood!

Grant Wynia & Amanda McCabe
First Data Bank & Market Research Director, Eli Lilly & Company

We have worked with Mary on several occasions, and she consistently provides invaluable expertise as well as dedication to providing the best service possible in representing us. We highly recommend Mary because she so reliably navigates the process of buying or selling a house. It’s a pleasure to work with her.

Jeffrey Goodwin
FRM, President, Crescendo Investments

You will never find another Realtor like Mary Wernke! We began using Mary to purchase and sell our homes as well as some rental/flip homes a few years ago and we could not be happier. Mary goes above and beyond to attend to every single detail of the real estate process. She helped us find and manage contractors, gave us staging and decorating advice and even worked with landscaping companies to fix unforeseen tree concerns. She is reliable, smart, savvy and the hardest working agent I have ever met. We trust her implicitly and would recommend her services to the closest friends and family.

John Sutton
Principal, Newpoint Services

I recently sold my first home and bought another with Mary helping me on both accounts. I have to say, I don’t think I could have done it without her! Mary truly listened to all my concerns and questions helping me through them all. Her attention to detail made the process so seamlessly for me. If I had it to do all over again, I would not change one thing.

Julie Currise
Eli Lilly and Company

Our experience was exceptional, and in the end, we found exactly what we were hoping to find. Mary (Wernke) was both personal and professional throughout our engagement. She listened exceptionally well, and quickly learned about us... our tastes, how we lived, what we were looking for... She showed us properties that she knew would suit us, and some that pushed our thinking a little, which was extremely helpful. Mary was always punctual and well prepared. She provided us with great market information to help educate us. And, she always followed-up... sending us pictures, sharing with us any notes she had taken, providing answers to any questions we had. Finally, once we found our perfect home, Mary guided us through the close and afterwards, always helping to tie up any "loose ends". Our experience couldn't have been better. Thank you, Mary!

Jim Schacht
Executive Director, Cummins Inc.

My husband and I met Mary Wernke last February while we were contemplating a move to Indianapolis. She was so warm and friendly that I knew immediately, that if we moved, she would be our realtor. When we came out for our house hunting trip in May, she drove us all over Indianapolis, Fishers, and Carmel, as we tried to figure out where we wanted to live. She was so helpful (and patient). When I found a house online that I wanted to see after we had already gone back to California, she drove over and videotaped the house, yard, AND neighborhood, and put it online for us to see! We ended up buying the house with all of Mary’s amazing help guiding us through the process from across the country. We couldn’t be happier. We love our house and our neighborhood!

Jacqueline & Brian Guy

Don’t miss a thing.

Be the first to know the inside scoop.